Could Macy have made a guest appearance?

[Tim]

Some may think this is pointless, as the show is cancelled, but I wonder, if the show had continued, could we have seen Macy again for a one off appearance?

Unlike the events of the firing of Shannen Doherty from the original show, twenty years earlier, Madeleine Mantock, who played Macy, left of her own accord.  The writers knew it was happening and prepared for it.  Madeleine was not fired.

And the fact that Madeleine allowed them to use pictures and footage of her (for flashbacks) showed that she seemed to be still on good terms with everyone (compare that to the original series, where Prue more or less became an unperson). 

So, I think that, if the right script came along, and if Madeleine was free, I think she might have done it.

How about the rest of you?

[matt]

Jan 6, 2023 0:31:26 GMT -5 Tim said:

Some may think this is pointless, as the show is cancelled, but I wonder, if the show had continued, could we have seen Macy again for a one off appearance?

Unlike the events of the firing of Shannen Doherty from the original show, twenty years earlier, Madeleine Mantock, who played Macy, left of her own accord.  The writers knew it was happening and prepared for it.  Madeleine was not fired.

And the fact that Madeleine allowed them to use pictures and footage of her (for flashbacks) showed that she seemed to be still on good terms with everyone (compare that to the original series, where Prue more or less became an unperson). 

So, I think that, if the right script came along, and if Madeleine was free, I think she might have done it.

How about the rest of you?

I really do think she could've made a return appearance if the right script came along.

Could've seen her being a ghost helping them.

[Melinda Halliwell]

Or appeared in Flashback if the show had done an episode like og Charmed's "Cat House".

Would've been nice if Kaela had met Macy in some shape or form I guess.

[Tim]

An episode like Cat House could have worked, since Madeleine had no issues with them using footage of her.

Would have been nice to have Kaela do something that Paige couldn't, namely meet her deceased Charmed predecessor.  After all, it was Macy's stem cells that saved Kaela's life.