As suggested already episode 18 is the standalone one to do with the Benders which I've done changing the title to fit more with the stories theme and changed officer Kathleen Hudak to Donna instead who works at the same police station as Jody and not Stillwater Minnesota so the location of this episode is Sioux Falls and not Hibbing Minnesota.
The guy kidnapped at the start Alvin is Donna's brother whose surname's Hanscum not Jenkins then.
One of the Benders called Jared's name is changed also so not to confuse him with Sam played by Jared Padalecki naturally.
Air Date: April 6th, 2006
Time Slot: 9:00 PM-10:00 PM EST on The WB
Season 1 Episode 18: "When The Hunter Becomes The Hunted."
TODAY SAM BECOMES THE PREY -
SIOUX FALLS SOUTH DAKOTA - A young boy, named Evan (Ryan Drescher), sees a man Alvin Hanscum (Jon Cuthbert) take out the garbage near his apartment then.
On the way back the man hears something and kneels down underneath a car to take a look.
He gets pulled in and disappears subsequent to which Evan screams out viewing.
THE ROADHOUSE NEXT DAY - Sam and Dean (Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles) are talking to Bobby Singer (Jim Beaver) and his wife Ellen (Samantha Ferris) about recent events reuniting with their dad and learning about Meg and Yellow Eyes on the side to which Ellen bays something will come up about the latter two hopefully which the boys nod agreeing.
Bobby tells them of a potential case in the meantime where a number of people in the local area have been disappearing recently with the man Alvin from the previous evening sighted as been the latest person obviously showing both Winchesters the days newspaper headline.
Sam wonders why that could be their type of case and not something police related which Bobby replies because of the rumours circulating this could be some 'Phantom Abductor' being how the missing person's vanished into thin air and have never came back.
"Alright," Dean says they'll have a crack promising to call if they info and keep the guys posted before Ellen and Bobby reply be careful goodbye as the brothers leave.
EVAN'S MOTHER'S APARTMENT - Disguised as state policemen, Sam and Dean interview Evan and his mother but don't get anything from them unfortunately except the fact Alvin was the brother of a local Sheriff downtown and noise Evan, heard of something moving away.
THE ROADHOUSE - The brothers head back and regroup discussing things with Ellen and Bobby that evening.
Sam heads for the Impala to get John's journal and hears a noise discovering that to be a stray cat.
Opening the boot he doesn't see someone sneak up behind and chriform him making Sam slope down before been dragged away.
Dean wondering where his brother notices the Impala's boot up and his car keys on the ground and a noticeable track leading away when he appears to find him missing.
"SAM!" He shouts before adding "SAMMY!" a few times alerting Ellen and Bobby who pop outside concerned what the commotion is.
All three go inside with Ash (Chad Lindberg) getting to work seeing what he can find out online.
Dean says he'll head to the police station next morning and pretend to report Sam missing to try and see if anything's been said about Alvin there.
Bobby warns Dean to be careful of Jody Mills because she works at the same police department Alvin's sister does and could become suspicious seeing him which the oldest Winchester comments he will.
SIOUX FALLS POLICE STATION NEXT MORNING - An officer named Donna (Brianna Buckmaster) storms out of a room walking over to Sheriff Jody (Kim Rhodes) blasting about what just happened with the Captain of the department and her concerns over her missing brother Alvin not been heard.
Jody agrees saying it's only been a little over 24 hours and he could come back wherever he went.
Donna remarks if her brother went away for an extended period of time he'd tell her where noting the 'Phantom Abductor' and everything.
Jody thinks that it might not be nothing before walking away as Dean comes in reporting Sam missing.
Donna goes over and helps him.
FARMHOUSE BARN - Sam wakes up finding himself inside a cage.
He notices someone across him surmising it could be the person who went missing recently Alvin Hanscum possibly.
Both men talk with Alvin mentioning his sister Donna whose a Sheriff hoping she discovers something and tries to find him.
Two hooded figures enter and leave food. Sam's astonished to find their captors are not supernatural beings but people then.
DOWNTOWN SIOUX FALLS - Dean comes off with the phone with Ash who identified a truck making a noise similar to what the witness reported sending him a picture of the trailer pulling out of the parking lot just after Sam left the bar which he tells Donna.
She seems slightly suspicious how he knows about that.
An old truck passes by giving off the same odd noise that matches what the boy Evan described which Dean follows.
Donna puts in a call to the police station asking for information on Dean which she back gets about the incident in St Louis Missouri.
OFF THE BEATEN TRACK - Dean finds the missing truck and shouts over to Donna who strolls over telling Dean she knows who he really is and that she should take him in.
Dean pleads her not to saying he just wants to find his brother which hits accord with Donna saying her brother's missing also who the police won't look for having not being gone long.
The other knows about that commenting maybe both were taken by the same thing or things and should look for them then.
Donna handcuffs Dean to the squad car instead before going up road to a house to investigate.
FARMHOUSE BARN - Sam manages to rip free an electrical cable which opens Alvin's cell door.
He suspects something's up but Alvin ignores him leaving with the youngest shouting the man to come back obviously.
The cell doors swing shut again and lock by remote.
Outside in the rain, Alvin finds a knife and runs, but is ambushed by a guy.
He keeps going but another man takes him down but then the two men drive him into a tripwire.
Finally satisfied with their game, the men kill Alvin as Sam hears his screams.
MAIN FARMHOUSE - Donna knocks on the front door to find teenager called Missy (Alexia Fast) answering it.
The girl acts strange and just smiles at her... as her father sneaks up and knocks Donna out.
OFF THE BEATEN TRACK - Dean tries grabbing the car antenna to pick the handcuffs as the family truck approaches.
He manages to get it loose and gets the cuffs off as the two men, brothers, arrive and spot the car and take it away.
FARMHOUSE BARN - Donna wakes up in a cell with Sam and talks with him.
Sam asks if she's Alvin's sister which Donna nods yes. He tells her what happened upsetting the woman.
Dean having found the Farmhouse and barn sneaks in reassuring the two he'll set them free once he's found a key that he goes leaves to search for then.
SIOUX FALLS POLICE STATION - Jody asks an officer if Donna's back yet which he replies no touting she did call though asking about someone who's described as Dean that his colleague recognises.
He mentions the man was looking for a missing person making Jody think what happened to Donna's brother might be a thing actually.
She asks Donna's last location and tells the desk sergeant to inform the Captain she's gone out on a potential lead.
FARMHOUSE BASEMENT - In the dark basement Dean finds jars filled with the brothers' "trophies" as well as photographs of them with their victims making him think he's walked right into 'The Texas Chainsaw Massacre'.
Going upstairs he finds a man cutting something while music plays on an old Victrola.
Dean stumbles across the girl, Missy, who stabs at him, pinning his jacket to the door frame.
She then calls for her dad, who shows up.
Dean gets uncaught from the knife and the two fight it out until another family member clubs him over the head.
OFF THE BEATEN TRACK - Arriving in the area Jody parks up getting out of her car noticing Donna's one not there.
Spying a path ahead she walks up cautiously handgun outstretched.
FARMHOUSE BASEMENT - The Benders as they're called both wake up Dean.
Pa Bender (John Dennis Johnston) boasts how his favorite hunt is human, and how they've done it for generations.
They want to know if Dean's disappearance will bring more cops before giving Dean the choice of selecting Donna or Sam.
When he doesn't answer Pa threatens to poke his eye out.
Dean picks Sam but Pa simply tells one of his sons to shoot first Sam then Donna afterward.
The oldest Winchester groans hearing that.
FARMHOUSE BARN - The brother Lee (Shawn Reis) lets Sam out, but he has the bracket from the cable he pulled down early and throws it at the guy. That buys him enough time to take the guy out and get his rifle, but it's busted then.
Pa and his other son Dodger (Kevin Kirzinger) go out to investigate and find Lee, unconscious, and the power cut off.
They search the barn for Sam and Donna.
Jody having found the place announces herself gun outstretched telling Pa and Dodger to put their hands over their heads and kneel on the ground whilst she arrests them both.
Dodger gets the best of her and throws Jody down preparing to shoot her.
Sam who's being shot at by Pa continually out maneuvers avoiding him.
Donna catches up punching him to the ground then goes to throw Dodger off Jody.
He pushes her back then fires at Sam who ducks, causing Dodger to shoot his father.
Jody knocks Dodger out then goes to find Dean who Sam notes is in the main Farmhouse.
When Pa laughs about killing Donna's brother, she goes to kill him but Sam tells her the best thing to do is arrest him along with Lee and Dodger so she doesn't lose her badge which she does then.
FARMHOUSE OUTSIDE - Donna and Sam walk out as Dean and Jody meet up with them.
Jody says they found Missy and locked her up in a cage.
Sam explains what he and Donna done and to call the incident in.
Donna mentions the brothers will have to make a statement down the station which the boys decline.
Jody asks why with Sam and Dean commenting they wouldn't know making her more suspicious about them as they leave.
THE ROADHOUSE THAT EVENING - Ellen, Bobby and the boys talk over the last few days with the older two glad Sam and Dean are safe.
Regarding Jody they'll have to keep a closer eye on her and make sure she doesn't find out anything which both parties agree on at the end.